Who’s Received the Quickest Mobile Broadband? Dash, Verizon and AT&T Speed Assessments

So you open up up your browser and hop more than to Google. You variety in some thing like:

“Who has the fastest mobile broadband?”

three sites that seem very acquainted pop up stating things like:

“BroadbandAccess Evolution Data Optimized (EV-DO) network from Verizon Wireless has been improved with EV-DO Rev. A to provide even quicker data speeds and increased efficiencies. Fast downloads – normal speeds of 600 Kbps to one.4 Mbps. Fast uploads – typical speeds of 500-800 Kbps.”

“With a Dash Cellular Broadband Card, you get average download speeds of 600-1400 Kbps, peaking at three.one Mbps, and 350-500 Kbps average add speeds, peaking at one.8 Mbps. Related to DSL, and about ten instances faster than employing a dial-up modem”

” AT&T gives the broadband velocity and responsiveness of BroadbandConnect…the most current 3G units offer common obtain throughput of 700 kbps to 1.seven Mbps for downloads and five hundred kbps to 1.two Mbps for add”


Just give it to me straight Doc. Speak English. How in the planet is an individual meant to determine out who’s the fastest with this ‘can’t sue me’ law firm-talk?

All the ranges look to overlap. Even looking at the optimum speeds, Verizon and Sprint search equivalent…until finally, that is, you comprehend they are only theoretical. A best circumstance circumstance which is not as well optimistic.

It truly is just like your speedometer’s selection that goes from mph to a hundred and twenty mph. Just because a hundred and twenty mph is on your dashboard does not mean your rusty sixteen 12 months previous Honda Civic Hatchback with the flashing engine verify gentle is gonna make it.

The firms also know you can’t contact them on it due to the fact ‘there are way too a lot of variables’. What have been the road situations like? How quick had been you likely? When last have you experienced a tune-up? What was the temperature like? Do you know how several cell cellphone towers have been in the region? How numerous satellites ended up positioned around you at the time? Or my personal favored ‘You have been most very likely roaming and we have no manage above other networks’.

It really is like trying to get fresh organic and natural vegetables at McDonald’s. It truly is just not gonna take place.

It just is what it is my good friend.

The only way down to the nitty gritty and feast on the raw reality is to get out into the wild. Outside the house of my very own testing, I attract on the ordeals of others from ComputerWorld, Gizmodo and jkOnTheRun. I will give you a fast chronological recap of what took place with every:

ComputerWorld – Which 3G Community Is The Greatest? – 05/thirteen/08


New York, New Jersey and Connecticut

Broadband Cards:

(AT&T) Sierra Wireless USBConnect 881, (Sprint) Novatel Wi-fi Ovation U727 and (Verizon) Sierra Wireless USB AirCard 595U

End result: AT&T experienced the maximum optimum velocity (1.6 Mbps), regular obtain velocity (755 Kbps) and upload pace (484 Kbps)

Gizmodo – The Definitive Coastline-to-Coastline 3G Data Take a look at – 12/seventeen/08


Austin, Boston, Chicago, New York Town, Portland, Raleigh-Durham, San Francisco and the Bay Spot

Broadband Playing cards:

AT&T’s Sierra USBConnect 881, Sprint’s Sierra Wi-fi Compass 597 and Verizon Wireless’s Novatel USB727

Results: Dash experienced the greatest countrywide typical down load velocity (one.4 Mbps) whilst AT&T (640 kbps) had the highest typical upload pace

jkOnTheRun – 3G SpeedTest: EV-DO vs. HSDPA in Phoenix – twelve/27/08

Area: Phoenix, AZ

Broadband Cards: Verizon Wi-fi USB727, AT&T USB Quicksilver

Benefits: Verizon had the maximum down load velocity (2.one Mbps) and upload pace (744 Kbps)

So here we have got 3 diverse checks all exhibiting a person else as the winner. 4gbredband is barely stunning. Cell broadband speeds do vary from place to spot. The only way to get a very clear winner is to test in multiple places, just take a pair averages and then see who comes out on leading.

Since Gizmodo’s check was the most extensive, it really is reasonable to say its also the most dependable. Dash is kicking butt in the cellular broadband game. Even if you only evaluate the tests Gizmodo executed in New York City alongside the exams ComputerWorld ran in NYC, Sprint nevertheless beats AT&T in obtain and add speed.

Dash is obviously the winner all round and supplies serious competitiveness in every single spot. If put collectively the simple fact that they are the fastest, greatest mobile broadband community, you have got a double whammy.

It’s no question that Andy Abramson of Doing work Everywhere suggests Sprint. He spends about $900 per thirty day period tests mobile broadband and wireless web relevant providers. Appears like he may know a thing or two.

To conquer a lifeless horse even additional…

I’ve personally analyzed it in excess of 1001 miles of highway at 70 miles for every hour (New Orleans to Jacksonville and Tampa to Atlanta). I had my link get dropped when…for 15 minutes overall. Which is strong.

Now ahead of we all begin bowing down to the awesome community that is Dash, ComputerWorld points out some things you ought to know:

“Using this engineering can be a little bit like being on a roller coaster. I identified that I could be screaming together at one.1Mbit/sec. only to have speeds slow to a crawl at 20Kbit/sec. a second afterwards. Which is because, as with all cellular service, speed and reliability count on a variety of circumstances, these kinds of as how considerably you are from a cell tower, how several other customers are related in your vicinity and how much info they are moving”.